The Great Question: A Story of Love and Mystery Featuring Legendary Actor Quirk!

Stepping into the cinematic realm of 1917 offers a fascinating glimpse into the nascent years of filmmaking, an era marked by silent storytelling, experimental techniques, and captivating performances. While giants like Chaplin and Keaton dominated the scene, there existed a treasure trove of lesser-known gems waiting to be rediscovered. One such gem is “The Great Question,” a short film that encapsulates the era’s charm with its intriguing storyline and the magnetic performance of legendary actor, George Quirk.

“The Great Question,” released in 1917 by the Thanhouser Company, follows the enigmatic journey of a young writer grappling with a profound philosophical dilemma. The narrative weaves together elements of romance, mystery, and social commentary, reflecting the concerns and aspirations prevalent in the early 20th century.

Unveiling the Narrative Tapestry:

Our protagonist, played by Quirk with his characteristic blend of intensity and vulnerability, finds himself at a crossroads. He is deeply enamored with a captivating young woman, but societal norms and personal insecurities cast a shadow over their budding relationship. As he delves into the depths of “The Great Question” – the central theme of the film – he encounters a series of cryptic clues and enigmatic characters who guide him towards self-discovery.

The narrative unfolds through a tapestry of interweaving storylines, each contributing to the overarching exploration of existential questions. We witness:

• The Writer’s Struggle: Quirk’s character wrestles with his own creative blocks, mirrored by his inability to articulate his feelings for the object of his affection. His journey towards answering “The Great Question” becomes a metaphor for breaking free from self-imposed limitations.

• The Enigmatic Love Interest: The female lead embodies both allure and enigma, representing the complexity of human relationships. She acts as a catalyst for the protagonist’s growth, challenging him to confront his insecurities and embrace vulnerability.

• A World in Transition: The film subtly reflects the social dynamics of 1917, a period marked by rapid industrialization, changing gender roles, and evolving moral values. “The Great Question” implicitly grapples with these shifts through its exploration of individual identity and societal expectations.

Visual Storytelling: A Masterclass in Silent Cinema:

“The Great Question,” like many films of the era, relies heavily on visual storytelling to convey its narrative. The Thanhouser Company, known for its meticulous production values, employed a range of cinematic techniques to enhance the viewing experience:

• Expressive Acting: Quirk’s performance is a masterclass in silent acting. He conveys a wide range of emotions – love, longing, frustration, and eventual enlightenment – through nuanced facial expressions, subtle gestures, and carefully calibrated movements.

• Atmospheric Cinematography: The film employs soft lighting and dramatic shadows to create an evocative atmosphere. Shots are often framed in a way that emphasizes the characters’ isolation or connection.

• Intertitles: Guiding the Viewer: Intertitles, short text segments inserted between scenes, play a crucial role in advancing the plot and providing context. They act as narrative bridges, clarifying dialogue and revealing character motivations.

Beyond Entertainment: A Cultural Snapshot:

“The Great Question,” though modest in scale compared to other cinematic spectacles of its time, offers valuable insights into early 20th century America.

Aspect	Insights
Social Norms	The film subtly reflects the evolving roles of men and women in society. Quirk’s character grapples with traditional expectations while simultaneously yearning for a more fulfilling relationship.
Philosophical Concerns	“The Great Question” itself serves as a thematic anchor, prompting reflection on existential dilemmas relevant even today: purpose, identity, and the meaning of life.
Artistic Innovations	The Thanhouser Company’s use of lighting, framing, and intertitles exemplifies the emerging artistry within silent cinema.

Rediscovering Cinematic Treasures:

While “The Great Question” might not be as widely known as some of its contemporaries, it stands as a testament to the creativity and innovation flourishing in early Hollywood. Quirk’s powerful performance anchors a compelling narrative that continues to resonate with audiences today. For those seeking a glimpse into the past and a chance to appreciate the roots of cinematic storytelling, “The Great Question” offers a rewarding experience.